Tasty Pizza

4.2 ( 248 reviews )

Checking... 10:30 AM - 12:00 AM See Hours

515 W Un St, Waterloo, IN 46793, United States

+1 260-837-2777

"Tasty Pizza," located at 515 W Un St, Waterloo, IN, has earned a stellar reputation among locals and travelers alike. Patrons like James Brown rave about its extensive menu, noting that every item, from the dough to the sauce, bursts with flavor. The Tasty Sub Melt with poppyseed sauce stands out as a crowd favorite alongside the hearty Meatzza and flavorful Chicken Garlic Pizza, leaving diners craving more.

Heather Glisson shared how a two-hour trip for pizza was well worth it, especially for the unique broccoli topping. Douglas Chapman praised the Tasty Supreme, complimenting its perfectly baked crust and harmonious toppings. He emphasized that the quality speaks volumes about the traditional family recipes since 1958. The rustic exterior of the building contrasts sharply with the exceptional pizza craftsmanship within, proving that greatness often lies behind humble facades.

Consistently, customers note the friendly service—both in-house and delivery. Benjamin Gilmour appreciated the prompt, courteous response during a breakdown. Overall, Tasty Pizza exemplifies a top-tier culinary experience, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Waterloo.

James Brown

Jun 23,2025

When I am driving north from the Fort I will jump off I-69 & drive the mile or so to get a sub or small pizza. The menu is MASSIVE. almost everything on it is full of taste. The dough, sauce, cheese...excellent. I live in the Fort, and have had Lexys, Jets, Redwood, and the chain brands...but Tasty Pizza is the best. The Tasty Sub Melt with poppyseed sauce is divine. All 'Meatzza' is very meaty, but the Chicken Garlic Pizza maybe my fave. The building looks like an old dump but don't be fooled...I can't rave enough about the dough, cheese and sauce. Tasty Pizza truly delivers Taste!

Heather Glisson

Jun 12,2025

Some of the best pizza around. I had it several years ago while visiting the area. Recently talked my husband into the 2 hour drive to get some pizza with broccoli on it. He thought I was crazy but he loved it!!! We are making the trip again tomorrow.

Douglas Chapman

May 24,2025

I recently savored the Tasty Supreme pizza from Tasty Pizza in Waterloo, Indiana, customizing it without green peppers for my first trial. The experience was nothing short of delightful. Right from the first bite, the crust impressed me with its perfect bake and texture. The toppings were cooked to perfection, each ingredient melding harmoniously while retaining its distinct taste. What stood out the most was the sauce — it had a unique flavor profile that set this pizza apart from others I’ve tried. Despite the older, somewhat worn appearance of the building, the quality and taste of the pizza spoke volumes about the family tradition of making "Pizza Fantastic Since 1958!" It’s a testament to not judging a book by its cover, or in this case, a pizzeria by its facade. I’m already looking forward to my next visit and would highly recommend Tasty Pizza to anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience in Waterloo. Their craftsmanship in pizza making is evident, and it’s no wonder they’ve been a culinary staple since 1958. Two thumbs up for Tasty Pizza!

Benjamin Gilmour

May 11,2025

I drive semi and had a a tire blow out right across from ups on hwy 6 so I wasn't able to make it to the truck stop they delivered to me the delivery girl was very nice and so was the gentleman on the phone taking my order

Destinee Fuleki-Parker

Apr 12,2025

My husband and I ordered from here a couple years ago when we lived in Auburn and then recently we moved to butler so we decided to try them again. And it was one of the best decisions we've made. The food is always delicious and fresh. Their delivery drivers are nice and delivery usually is less than their estimate. I recommend the chicken bacon ranch pizza or the chicken club sub and their nacho cheese.

Lucy Meeks

Mar 29,2025

First time order. Delivery was close to time quoted and pizza was great. Hand tossed crust was generous and lots of toppings. Will definitely order again, very impressed they delivered here at Story Lake

Amber Bradbury-Huepenbecker

Mar 24,2025

My husband and I, ordered from Tasty Pizza last Saturday for the first time, and it was absolutely delicious. So we ordered from them again today, and we were not disappointed. We got the taco pizza & all meat pizza, both were so yummy.

Zayden Homeschooling

Mar 13,2025

Where to start with this place. The menu is PACKED with many different choices that includes way more than just pizza. Our waitress was OUTSTANDING. She was very quick with her service and was amazing at her job. The pizza was the best part though. It was probably the best pizza I ever had in my whole lifetime of living. It had a great crunchy crust, yet at the same time, it wasn't too thick or too thin to enjoy! The atmosphere was very cute too, it felt like I was walking into a 1980's vintage environment. It was very welcoming at first sight and I am so excited to come back. I love the local vibes this place brings too, just so cute, warm, and welcome. So yeah, 5/5 AMAZING SERVICE AND FOOD IS SOME OF THE BEST I EVER HAD!!!!!

Tasty Pizza

Amenities and More

Photos

Reviews For Tasty Pizza

Add a Review

Location

Appreciated by Others